Join our community
Receive the TR Together newsletters.
Projective identification, valency, and role responsiveness in clinical work
Joseph Sandler’s concept of Role Responsiveness is deceptively familiar yet continues to reveal new depth in clinical practice. It describes the therapist’s unconscious, often involuntary tendency to respond to a patient’s projections by inhabiting a role, expressing the patient’s internal world in lived form within the analytic dyad. Sandler (1976, 1983) framed this as a way of understanding countertransference not as error, but as information: the therapist’s feelings and behaviours become a tool for discerning the patient’s unconscious communications.
A core focus of this presentation is the role of responsiveness in action. Through case material and video illustrations, participants explored forms of role induction and how therapists navigate the tension between identification and reflective stance. Questions addressed included: How does the therapist recognise being drawn into an unconscious role? How can these experiences be used therapeutically without losing observing capacity? Special attention is given to scenarios where therapists are pulled into multiple, conflicting roles, and to manifestations of role responsiveness beyond the consulting room, including supervision.
This seminar also revisited the role responsiveness as a living clinical concept, exploring its development in Sandler’s work on role, identity, and internal object relations, and its intersections with projective identification (Klein, 1946), valency (Bion, 1961), and contemporary ideas of enactment and mutual influence. While originating in individual analysis, role responsiveness is particularly relevant in couple therapy, where interlocking projections create complex unconscious fields that the therapist experiences and negotiates.
Why does this concept continue to fascinate clinicians? This session explores its theoretical lineage from Sandler’s original formulations, his dialogue with Bion’s valency and containment, and the intersections with Klein’s projective identification. We will consider how role responsiveness reframes countertransference as a form of projective participation, where the therapist unconsciously takes up roles that give shape to the patient’s internal world. Participants will be invited to think about how the analytic setting itself, both internal and external, structures these unconscious exchanges and how they can be used to deepen understanding rather than derail process.
What does role responsiveness look and feel like in the room? Through case material and video illustration, we will explore different forms of role induction and the therapist’s navigation between identification and reflection. How does the therapist know when they have been drawn into an unconscious role, and what allows them to use this without losing their observing stance? Particular attention will be given to cases, where the therapist is invited, and pressured, into multiple and conflicting roles at once. We will also look at how role responsiveness manifests in teams, supervision, and institutional life, broadening its reach beyond the consulting room.
Dr Avi Shmueli is a Training and Supervising Analyst of the British Psychoanalytical Society and also a Couple Psychoanalytic Psychotherapist. Having originally trained as a clinical psychologist, he worked in the NHS, Tavistock Relationships, and then the Anna Freud Centre. He currently works in private practice, supervises the work of the Divorce and Separation Consultation Service at Tavistock Relationships and teaches at the British Psychoanalytical Society and at the Psychoanalysis Unit of University College London.
He is a clinician committed to psychoanalysis as a theory for understanding the mind and as a mode of clinical practice. In addition to working as a psychoanalyst, he has pursued the application of psychoanalytic concepts to empirical research and the fields of both family and criminal law. In doing so, he has developed the strong belief that psychoanalytic concepts must be made accessible, relevant and fun!
Standard Registration: £60
Trainee, NHS staff and Third Sector: £51
Trainee and NHS Discount: To qualify for this offer you need to be taking a course which provides core practitioner training in counselling or psychotherapy that is at least 1 year full time or two years part time and recognised by the BACP or UKCP. TR Together reserve the right to ask to see evidence of training being undertaken. Please contact [email protected] to recieve the discount code.
Group Rates (for 4 or more): Contact [email protected] for customised pricing.
Alumni: If you are a TR Alumni (TRAPC member) please email [email protected] for a discount code to add at checkout
Your CPD Certificate will be available to download from your TR Together account within 48 hours of purchase.